Aluminum vs Vinyl Fence: 8 Factors to Consider

Last time, we compared vinyl fences vs wood fences.

Vinyl won, beating wood in 6 of the 9 categories we discussed.

Today, we’re diving into another exciting showdown: aluminum vs. vinyl fencing.

You’ll quickly see that these two materials have unique characteristics that set them apart.

In the end, it all comes down to your needs and which material works best to secure and delimit your property.

When it comes to fences, there are different options depending on your needs—whether it’s a front yard fence, a privacy fence for the backyard, or decorative options for added style.

If you build a privacy fence, vinyl fences are the best option. If you want a lifetime fence, you should install aluminum fences. The other factors are just a thing of choice and taste.

Aluminum and vinyl fences are almost equal in beauty and classiness. For instance, go for aluminum if you want a wrought iron fence's imposing and sturdy appearance without the weight, maintenance, and expense.

If you like the classiness of wood fences but want to avoid extensive maintenance, vinyl is the perfect choice.

Regarding vinyl fence colors, nowadays, manufacturers offer a wide range of hues like tan, gray, wood grain, black, etc.

When considering the beauty and design attributes of these two types of fences, there isn’t a clear “winner.” This round will end in a tie.

Score: Aluminum Fence: 1; Vinyl Fence: 1

Aluminum fences come in a range of styles that fit perfectly with your lawn.

Whether your land is flat or sloped, you won't have to worry about unsightly gaps or awkward transitions. Plus, you can add spikes for extra security when installing your aluminum fence.

When it comes to vinyl fences, you get even more variety of styles than aluminum fences.

You can opt for privacy fences, picket fences that mimic wood, and even post-and-rail fences. Also, vinyl mimics ornamental wrought iron fences.

Vinyl fence is victorious in this round for its incredible versatility, variety of styles & imitation capabilities.

Score: Aluminum Fence: 1; Vinyl Fence: 2

Is privacy a big thing for your new fence project?

You should install a vinyl fence if you need a backyard privacy fence to block out your neighbors, the busy street, or the ugly yard next door.

Also, regarding privacy, vinyl fences are ideal for pool enclosures.

So, in this round, the vinyl privacy fence is the clear winner.

Score: Aluminum Fence: 1; Vinyl Fence: 3

Vinyl and aluminum fences are in the same price range. Another tie in this furious duel.

Score: Aluminum Fence: 2; Vinyl Fence: 4

Vinyl fence may take the lead in terms of privacy, but when it comes to material sturdiness, aluminum fence beats vinyl by far.

With its moderate weight and resilience, aluminum fences can create a robust barrier that will safeguard your loved ones and home for decades.

Score: Aluminum Fence: 3; Vinyl Fence: 4

A vinyl fence lasts 30 years. That’s awesome.

But few things compare to and outperform aluminum fences. Why?

Since aluminum is lightweight and robust, it enjoys unsurpassed durability!

When properly maintained, aluminum fences have a lifespan of 50+ years. That’s almost a lifetime. Mind-blowing!

Now, aluminum ties the fight.

Score: Aluminum Fence: 4; Vinyl Fence: 4

Guess what???...

This fierce battle is far from over. Both aluminum and vinyl fences are maintenance-free materials.

How do you maintain your aluminum or vinyl fence as beautiful as the first day you installed it?

You only need to wash the fence with water and soap occasionally, and that’s all it usually takes to take care of your vinyl or aluminum fence.

Unlike wood fences, vinyl and aluminum resist water damage, mold, termites, warping, rotting, and deterioration, making them a smart, long-term investment.

So, once again, we have a tie. Without a doubt, this battle has been intense.

Score: Aluminum Fence: 5; Vinyl Fence: 5

Aluminum is the 13-chemical element in the periodic table. We can’t say the same of vinyl because it’s a synthetic material.

So, what’s more eco-friendly?

A metal created by nature or a plastic made by man?

Aluminum wins this round because of recycling, and it gives you the peace of mind that you are investing in a material that doesn’t increase your carbon footprint as the manufacturing of plastic would.

Score: Aluminum Fence: 6; Vinyl Fence: 5

This debate was a close one.

Even though aluminum managed to win this battle 6 to 5 against vinyl, the war is far from over.

So, which is better for you? If you build a privacy fence, vinyl fences are the best option. If you want a lifetime fence, you should install aluminum fences.

Your decision will be based primarily on these two factors: privacy and longevity.

The other factors are just a thing of choice and taste. With aluminum and vinyl fences, you get almost the same price, beauty, classiness & maintenance needs.

If you're still unsure about which fence material to choose, explore the benefits of both vinyl and aluminum fences to find the best fit for your needs.

For expert guidance and top-notch craftsmanship in fence installation, contact ESP Fencing LLC today!