Treated vs. Cedar Pickets: Learn the Pros, Cons & Differences

Blog

Treated vs. Cedar Pickets: The Battle of Strength, Style, and Savings

If you're considering building a fence, chances are you've encountered the debate: treated wood pickets or cedar pickets?

It's a choice that might seem simple at first glance, but once you start digging, you'll see there’s more to it than meets the eye.

After more than a decade of working with fences and helping homeowners design their perfect outdoor spaces, I can confidently say this: choosing a suitable picket material can make or break your fence project.

But don’t worry—I’m here to help you sort through the noise and determine what’s best for you and your yard.

Let’s dive into the nitty-gritty of treated and cedar pickets to see how they stack up!

Defining What Are Treated and Cedar Pickets?

Before jumping into the pros and cons, we should be on the same page about these materials.

● What Are Treated Wood Pickets?

These are typically pine or fir pickets chemically treated to resist rot, insects, and decay. The treatment process forces preservatives deep into the wood, which boosts its durability.

● Cedar Pickets:

Cedar pickets are made from—you guessed it—cedar wood.

Naturally resistant to insects and rot, cedar doesn’t need chemical treatments to hold up over time. Plus, it’s known for its rich color, tight grain, and signature earthy scent.

You can improve the resistance to rot and bugs by staining cedar fences.

Treated vs. Cedar Pickets: Let’s Clash These Fence Materials

Treated vs. Cedar Pickets: Which One Lasts Longer?

Regarding longevity, both options hold their own, but there are some key differences.

Thanks to the chemical treatment, these pickets can stand up to harsh conditions. They’re less likely to rot or be eaten by termites, even in humid or wet climates.

However, they are prone to warping, splitting, or cracking over time— if not maintained.

Cedar naturally contains oils and tannins, a natural defense against rot and bugs. It’s less likely to warp than treated wood, but it’s also softer. This means it can dent or scratch if exposed to heavy impact.

If you’re in an area with high moisture levels or many bugs, treated pickets might have a slight edge. But for overall stability and less warping, cedar comes out on top. With proper care, cedar can last significantly longer than pressure-treated wood.

Cedar: 1st Round Winner

Beauty Is in the Grain Now: Which Looks Better?

Let’s face it—a fence isn’t just about keeping your yard secure. It’s also a big part of your home’s curb appeal.

These start with a greenish tint from the treatment process, which fades to gray over time if left untreated. You can paint or stain to suit your style, but treated pickets don’t have much natural beauty to offer.

Cedar is a showstopper right out of the gate.

Its warm, reddish-brown tones and tight grain pattern make it a favorite for homeowners looking for a natural, elegant look.

Even as it ages, cedar weathers into a silvery gray that many find charming.

If looks matter most to you, you should always pick cedar.

Cedar: 2nd Round Winner

Which Is Easier to Care For Cedar or Treated Pickets?

Nobody wants to spend their weekends babysitting a fence. Here’s how these two materials compare when it comes to upkeep:

While durable, treated wood requires consistent maintenance to keep it looking good and functioning well. You’ll need to seal or stain it every 2-3 years to prevent warping and cracking.

Cedar doesn’t demand as much attention. It’s naturally resistant to most issues, and while staining can enhance its appearance, it’s not a must.

If you’re looking for a low-maintenance option, cedar takes the lead.

Cedar: 3rd Round Winner

Cost: How Much Are We Talking?

Budget is often the deciding factor, so let’s break it down:

Treated wood is usually more affordable upfront. If you’re building a large fence, this can make a big difference in the overall cost.

Cedar is a premium wood, so it’s going to cost more. That said, its durability and natural beauty might save you money in the long run on repairs and maintenance.

Treated wood wins in the short term, but cedar can be a better investment if you think long-term.

Treated vs. Cedar Pickets: 4th Round Is a Draw

Environmental Impact: Which Is More Eco-Friendly?

In today’s world, many homeowners are thinking about sustainability.

The chemicals used in treated wood can harm the environment, mainly if the wood isn’t disposed of properly.

As a natural, untreated wood, cedar is biodegradable and environmentally friendly.

Cedar is the greener choice, hands down.

Cedar: 5th Round Winner

Crunch Time: Make Your Choice Between Treated and Cedar Pickets!

Here’s the deal: the “right” picket depends on your priorities.

Treated pickets are a solid option if you’re focused on saving money upfront or need a fence that can handle harsh conditions.
If you want a beautiful, low-maintenance, and eco-friendly fence, cedar pickets are hard to beat.

And Here Is Our Winner in the Treated vs. Cedar Pickets:

Out of five rounds, cedar won all of them. Leaving the scoreboard 5-1.

So you should pick cedar pickets over treated wood.

Yet both options can create a stunning and sturdy fence—especially when installed by our crafty builders.

Ready to Build the Fence of Your Dreams?

Whether you’re team treated wood or team cedar, one thing’s for sure: the right fence can transform your outdoor space.

If you’re still on the fence (pun intended!) about which material to choose, contact our local fence builders, who can guide you through the process.

Your yard deserves the best, and planning allows you to create a fence that lasts for years.